In a development that has sent shockwaves through the European academic community, the European Commission has abruptly withdrawn its long-standing legal challenge against Italy over the discriminatory treatment of lettori – foreign language lecturers – in Italian universities.
The reversal comes despite decades of legal battles and four European Court of Justice (ECJ) rulings, dating back to 1989, all unequivocally condemning Italy’s breaches of EU law concerning equal treatment, wages, and pensions.
On 22 July 2025 Mario Nava, director general for employment, social affairs and inclusion wrote to ALLSI chair David Petrie, abandoning the lawsuit and saying:
In the light of the information received and statements made by the Italian authorities, the Commission considered that the Court case could not be further pursued since the grievances raised in the application to the Court in case C-519/23 had been resolved. In the light of the information received and statements made by the Italian authorities, the Commission considered that the Court case could not be further pursued since the grievances raised in the application to the Court in case C-519/23 had been resolved and the application has to be withdrawn from the Court at the earliest possible moment. The relevant Commission decision was made on 17 July 2025. Please be informed that your complaint registered under number CPLT(2011)00960 is hereby closed.
Due to the urgency to withdraw, which can be identified as exceptional circumstances in this case, in accordance with point 10 of Annex 1 to Communication ‘EU Law: Better Results through Better Application’ (OJ C 18, 19.1.2017, p. 10), the complainants could not be informed about the decision to withdraw in advance.
David Petrie said: “It is absolutely impossible to give any credence to this statement at all. On 31 March 2025, accompanied by my lawyer, Prof. Avv. Lorenzo Picotti, I met with Francesco Corti a member of Roxana Mînzatu’scabinet in their office in Brussels with documented evidence of pay slips, pension slips and tax returns of lettori still awaiting compensation.”
Reacting to Mr Nava’s letter of 22 July 2025, ALLSI wrote to Ursula von der Leyen’s head of legal services Mr Daniel Calleja-Crespo on 23 July 2025 saying, “there is good reason to conclude that Italy is breaching the principle of sincere cooperation enshrined in Article 4(3) of the Treaty” and asking him to put a stay on the Commission’s “hasty and thoroughly unjustifiable” withdrawal from the Court case C-519/23.
Professor Avv. Lorenzo Picotti said: “The decision is incomprehensible and should also be criticised on legal grounds. The Commission only takes into account the arguments put forward by the Italian Government, it does not consider evidence provided by ALLSI and other lecturers, or show that any “useful result” has been demonstrated at all. Therefore, Italy cannot be said to have fulfilled its obligations to fully implement European Union law and the judgments of the Court ofJustice, in particular that of 18 July 2006, C-119/04. We are considering what steps to take in response to this unfair decision, including appeals to the European Court of Human Rights.”
Case history
The European Court of Justice has ruled, four times, 1989, 1993, 2001 and 2006 finding breaches of EU law that prohibit illegitimate discrimination based on nationality, concerning equal treatment, equal and fair wages and pensions under EU single market rules.
In 2011 following protests by the lettori and in the European Parliament the Commission opened what it calls a Pilot scheme to find a faster negotiated solution. This failed to produce any useful result and 12 years later the Commission, on 14 July 2023, decided to take Italy back to the ECJ and ask the Court, case C-519/23[to]:
declare that the Italian Republic has failed to fulfil the obligations imposed by Article 45 TFEU, not having reconstructed the former assistants’ careers in order to guarantee the economic treatment due to them and the corresponding payment of arrears.





