EL Gazette asks the pertinent question: “Why now,” after the European Commission dropped its long-running ‘Lettori’ case against Italy?

Unfortunately, no clear evidence is available, but there has been much speculation: was it a favour from Ursula von der Leyen to Italian premier Giorgia Meloni to keep her onside in the tariff war with President Donald Trump? Or was it solidarity with the EU position on Ukraine? One could add other possibilities and take their pick. While speculation is opaque, the past shows how the dice are loaded against the migrant worker seeking fair and equal treatment.
“Che stronzata! What a load of ****,” says the Italian partner of one of my colleagues.
The scene is Luxembourg, at the European Court of Justice, on 18 July 2006. Directly in front of me, in the public benches, sits the outraged partner, three metres away from 13 judges from all over the EU in the Court’s Grand Chamber. He swiftly apologizes with a sharp, short, clipped “chiedo scuse,” sorreey, as the Italian State Advocate pirouettes, tugging on his toga and rounding on his errant fellow citizen, booming, “I am – the representative – of the Republic – of Italy.”
The good lawyer had been in full flow, explaining to the honourable judges how the foreign lecturers (lettori) were being reimbursed for wage arrears in the Italian universities where they work. Several lettori were sitting in the court with payslips that said the opposite.
The Commission did not challenge the evidence put to the Court by the Italian Advocate General. “Che stronzata!” was the nearest challenge the judges were going to hear, and it did not count as evidence.
There is a serious point here. An individual citizen of an EU member state has the right, under Article 45 of the Treaty, to migrate within the single market and enjoy equal treatment regarding pay, employment, and pensions. However, they have no direct right of access to the court to enforce that right. No direct access means no justice. You rely either on the goodwill of the Commission to state your case for you or for an Italian judge to seek preliminary guidance on a point of law from the Court of Justice before ruling. At the highest level of appeal court, the judges are Treaty-bound to refer. But there is no appeal process if they don’t. And they don’t.
The Court of Justice, in a 2001 ruling, accepted that Italian legislation pegging salaries and pensions to at least that of part-time tenured researchers provided a framework for removing illegitimate discriminatory pay and pensions. That should have been the end of it. Indeed, hundreds of colleagues received compensation for wage arrears. But then the Italian state leapfrogged the ECJ rulings by introducing retroactive legislation that put an end to the salary parameter the ECJ had approved.
In November 2013, the Commission, after consulting with the Italian authorities, claimed that we had been paid and requested the closure of our petition. Parliament refused, saying a simple examination of our payslips proved the opposite.
Now, fast forward to the morning of 31 March 2025. I am sitting in Brussels with my lawyer, preparing for our afternoon meeting with Mr. Francesco Corti, a cabinet member to Executive Vice-President, Commissioner Roxana Mînzatu.
At 11:47, an email arrives from David Dion, the Commission civil servant chief now handling our case. In February and September of 2023, the Commission had given an undertaking to keep me informed of how the most recent infringement proceedings were developing but had failed to do so until now. I phoned his office to ask if he would attend the afternoon meeting; his assistant told me she would get back to me. She never did. And nobody from the office in charge of the file attended.
Mr. Corti informed us that he knew very little – almost nothing – about the case. He seemed alarmed when I asked him if the Commission really wanted to win it.
On 27 July 2025, the Commission wrote to me saying it had closed the case.
But we should not be surprised; the European Union has no other legal reality than that of an international agreement between the governments of its member states. The free movement of goods and capital is taken seriously, while we are once again handled like a crate of tomatoes in a mob-run market.





