Home2025 IssuesReframing ELT guided by Chinese student experiences

Reframing ELT guided by Chinese student experiences

Dr Clare Watson, author of a recently published book ‘Teaching English to Chinese Students: Voices from UK Higher Education’, shares her reflections on working in the ELT landscape for the past three decades.

Before spotlighting key aspects of my recent research, captured in my book ‘Teaching English to Chinese Students: Voices from UK Higher Education’, I share a synopsis of my professional connection to the world of English language teaching (ELT).

Following a spell of working in a radio environment in the UK that had left me discontented with my daily work existence, I relocated to Greece (with my newly gained TEFL certificate) and began teaching English to young learners and adults.

From there, for the following couple of years, I continued to teach English as a Foreign Language (EFL) in Greece, followed by English for Academic Purposes (EAP) in the UK on short term contracts (often zero hours), receiving low wages and becoming more and more mindful of the volatility of my professional status.

Yet, despite these conditions and concerns, I acknowledged that my role as an English language tutor, made me feel ‘alive’ and I decided way back then in the mid 90’s to continue along this career path, to upskill, develop professionally and personally and dedicate myself to what seemed like an inevitable trajectory. Since that time, I have undertaken several EAP roles, in both management and tutor capacities in China, Ireland, the UK and Vietnam.  

Thus, working in an international education environment that enhances intercultural understanding and stimulates intellectual curiosity continues to this day. Now, three decades removed from those early experiences, I will share in this article the core themes of my book and the inspiration that led to its creation.

Based on my doctoral thesis, the book evolved from my fascination with China as a country, my gratification of working with Chinese students in a teaching and learning context, and my involvement in, and observation of, EAP as an academic discipline. The book outlines a narrative inquiry study that, through the eyes of the participants (Chinese students), explores how they understand and make meaning of studying EAP in a UK HE pathway education setting.

For purposes of contextualisation and clarity, I discuss the commodification of Western HE and the positioning of Chinese students within this space, some common negative perceptions (large culture approaches) of Chinese students and misinformed justifications that continue to pervade ELT domains, aspects of Orientalism in Western universities today, EAP (background, purpose and approaches), and recent Chinese Education Reforms. The latter foregrounds how recent Chinese Education Reforms seek to encourage creative thinking, problem solving, dialogic and democratic curriculum, and purposeful facilitation of individual growth and flourishment. Such education values are often viewed as Western centric and deemed void within the education system in China.

Having witnessed repeated exchanges in EAP staff rooms that refer to the inability of Chinese students to speak up in class, to engage in critical thinking, to understand and question the meaning of evidence to support their academic writing, I wanted to explore how Chinese students interpret their time in this study context. Through a thematic analysis of a rich set of qualitative interview data, gathered from the stories that the participants shared, emerged three core themes: Motivations, Experiencing Education: China and the UK, and Critical Thinking and Chinese Students. Comparisons are made, by the participants, between their education experience in China and in the UK to help them understand and make meaning of their period of EAP study. They share their feelings of being stifled by a prescriptive EAP curriculum that requires them to hurtle through tasks and activities to pass summative exams (there is a heavy assessment load) and move on to the next stage of their academic journey.

Each participant demonstrates an ability to think critically, even going so far as suggesting that our Western way of encouraging critical thinking verges on Western political indoctrination. They provide their own ruminations around some challenges they face regarding oral communication, relationship building with the Western tutor, and the development of writing skills and they intellectualise why this may be so. They are cognisant of the stereotyping that they are often subjected to and show no evidence of passivity and lack of engagement. I am privileged to listen and watch, as some of the participants articulate their experiences with confidence and openness.

Overall, findings support my own assumptions that EAP (in this instance created and delivered by a private pathway education provider) often falls short of providing this international student population with an education experience that is intrinsic in nature. In other words, there is minimal opportunity proffered for students to flourish and embark on individual growth, as they are embroiled in the world of credentialism and marketisation of education, that prioritises an overload of exam preparation.

It is not my intention to further homogenise our visiting Chinese students but rather to heighten our understanding of them through consideration of social, historical and cultural influences, while questioning our own pedagogical approaches, as English language tutors and leaders. I draw upon Dewey who, as highlighted by Wang and Weir (2007, p76), while evidencing his interest in China, proposed that it is not to be naively understood as an ‘alien political morphology’ but rather treated with respect and understanding as a country that is politically and economically different and fascinating in many respects. This I endorse in relation to our Chinese students and to that end, I hope that my research supports a higher level of understanding while offering recommendations that include a re-orientation of some (not all) EAP programmes, a review of Western university internationalisation strategies and implementation of these strategies, and an increase in academic dialogue between China and the UK.

I, myself, have moved on from being a novice EAP tutor in China in 2004, where I questioned my ability to encourage students to participate in lessons and often considered them to be obedient and silent. We have come a long way since then and I am optimistic that many English language tutors working with Chinese students may not recognise any of the challenges that I discuss here. However, there are still many (and I meet them daily in my education environment) that struggle to comprehend what they believe to be common Chinese classroom behavioural characteristics, and worryingly they make no attempt to understand. Deeply understanding our Chinese students and managing their expectations, while reflecting on how we can adapt will allow for a teaching and learning environment that is more meaningful for all involved.

This should expand to Western university academic circles as it is not, I believe, the sole responsibility of English language professionals. As referred to in the concluding part of my book, I call on Western educators to recognise that our Chinese students sit alongside all students, international and domestic, in their right to experience a UK (or UK associated) education that provides them with opportunities to sing loudly, as global citizens, on a global stage. After all, surely it is not their role to improve the economic standing of many Western university establishments by contributing to their dwindling income pots.

While this article can only offer an introduction to the discussion and themes of the book, I hope it may trigger a heightened interest in how we as English language educators can work closely with Chinese students to ensure we offer the highest quality education possible.

Reference

Wang, J. C. and Weir, D. John Dewey in China: To Teach and to Learn, State University of New York Press, 2007.ProQuest eBook Central. Available at: https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/gla/detail.action?docID=3407404 (last accessed 03 August 2022).

Image courtesy of Library
Clare Watson
Clare Watson
Clare Watson is currently a centre director for a pathway education provider at the International Study Centre at the University of Aberdeen, UK. She has worked in various English language teaching environments around the globe, in teaching and leadership capacities. Her research interests include teaching English to Chinese students, EAP and international education.
OTHER POSTS
- Advertisment -

Latest Posts