Continuing EL Gazette’s ‘Fresh Eyes’ series, Swaansh Mahat makes the case for classroom tasks that reveal where readers really get stuck.
An instruction can be grammatically correct and still leave its reader unable to proceed. In an English lesson, that gap offers a useful reason to revise. Instead of asking only whether a student has used the imperative accurately, a teacher can ask whether another student can complete the intended task from the written text.
The task need not involve elaborate equipment. A teacher could ask learners to describe how to arrange a small set of paper shapes into a particular pattern. One pair writes the instructions without showing the finished pattern. Another pair tries to produce it. The difference between the intended and actual arrangement becomes material for a discussion about language.
The crucial condition is that the writer must not rescue the reader halfway through. A gesture towards the correct corner or an explanation of what a pronoun meant can conceal a problem in the text. The first attempt should therefore have a short period in which readers record questions but work from the instructions alone. Afterwards, questions can become evidence for revision.
This is consistent with the Council of Europe’s action-oriented approach, which organises learning around realistic scenarios and a collaborative task or product, with learners deciding how to accomplish it and teachers supplying support (Council of Europe, n.d.). The proposed classroom exercise applies that principle to a modest written product whose use can be observed.
Readers should not be treated as examiners trying to catch the writer out. They can note the point at which a choice became unclear: which shape, which edge, whose left, what happens next. A record of the question is more useful than a verdict that the instructions were bad. It directs attention to the relationship the sentence failed to establish.
The writer then has several possible repairs. A repeated noun may be clearer than a pronoun. A reference point may settle what left means. A numbered step may need to be divided because it hides two actions. These are choices about a reader’s needs, rather than a demand to replace every ordinary word with a more advanced one.
A second reader should try the revised version. Asking the same pair to repeat the task would make the result difficult to interpret because they now know the intended pattern. A fresh pair provides a better check of whether the text has become clearer. Even then, one successful attempt is feedback on this task, not proof that a learner has mastered instructional writing.
The teacher still has a substantial role. Before the activity, the class may need language for sequence, position and clarification. Afterwards, the teacher can distinguish an ambiguous instruction from an unfamiliar word or a reader’s accidental omission. A problem in the completed pattern should start an inquiry, rather than automatically count as a writing error.
The activity also needs an accessible design. Learners should not be assessed on fine motor skills when the intended outcome concerns English. Objects can be larger, readers can describe an arrangement orally or another participant can move pieces under their direction. The teacher should identify which language skill is being examined and keep other demands proportionate.
For assessment, a short commentary on the revision can be as revealing as the final text. The writer can identify one reader question, explain the change made in response and consider whether that change introduced another difficulty. This gives the teacher a view of the learner’s judgement, without requiring a long reflective essay after a small task.
Procedural writing is often taught as a finished genre with recognisable verbs and sequence words. Letting a reader use the text gives those features a purpose. The lesson ends with a revised set of instructions and a clearer account of why it changed. Accuracy remains part of the work, joined by the practical question of what the reader can now do.
References
Council of Europe (n.d.) The action-oriented approach. Strasbourg: Council of Europe. Available at the linked page (Accessed: 4 November 2026).





