Teachers are hopeful yet hesitant about AI. Gill Ragsdale reports.
Language teachers value the use of AI in preparing lessons but remain hesitant
about using it in the classroom due to ethical concerns and lack of professional development, according to a systematic review by Belli Li and colleagues at Purdue University College of Education, West Lafayette, USA, Columbia University, New York, USA and Cambridge University, UK.
As the use of AI has increased among both teachers and students, this review sought to identify how teachers are adapting and integrating AI into their teaching. The authors identified 23 studies, 2022-2024, investigating teachers’ perceptions of AI, what influenced its use, as well as teachers’ competency and training.
The most positive and optimistic responses concerned the use of AI to support lesson planning, creating materials and providing written feedback. AI generated feedback on written work was reported as particularly useful, although this was also usually supplemented with personalised feedback, oral feedback and peer feedback.
While teachers were generally positive about using AI to create content, there was also some anxiety about the quality and in particular the need to verify the accuracy of that content, including any references.
Teachers were generally more hesitant about actually using AI in the classroom, however. In writing activities, AI was generally seen as more acceptable in the early stages such as outlining. When used beyond that point, concerns were raised regarding academic integrity (plagiarism) and the erosion of authentic language learning.
Many teachers reported feeling overwhelmed by the complexity and rapid development of AI tools and the most consistently recorded negative view of AI related to how its use might erode the role of the human teacher – perhaps even replacing them altogether. (A view echoed across many other professions.) Anxiety about the use of AI did tend to diminish over time with increasing experience, however.
Many teachers reported feeling overwhelmed by the complexity and rapid development of AI tools and the most consistently recorded negative view of AI related to how its use might erode the role of the human teacher – perhaps even replacing them altogether.
The majority of teachers (as many as 95.6% in one study) cited lack of training as a major challenge. Knowledge gaps were categorised into three major domains:
- Limited understanding of how AI works and consequently the capabilities and limits of different tools.
- Practical skills for example in prompt engineering and detecting AI-generated text from students.
- Practical guidance and expertise in navigating ethical issues such as AI bias and student privacy.
Successful professional development helped to shift teacher’s views form seeing AI as putting their own jobs at risk to seeing AI as an assistant and collaborator. However, there were only three such professional training courses outlined in the review, reflecting the dire lack of professional development in this area. These examples were able to demonstrate, however, that experience in using AI tools alongside discussion of the ethical issues can significantly boost teacher confidence and competence.
Going forward, the authors make a strong recommendation for a two-phase
training strategy, beginning with using AI for lesson planning, making materials and administrative tasks before progressing to more complex classroom applications – and this training should be ongoing.
AI is one area where our students our likely to be far ahead of their teachers, leaving the juggernaut of educational policy struggling to adjust course. As Sal Khan, founder of Khan Academy, says in his Ted talk:
“We’re scared of AI, but we’re also embracing AI. We think kids will just give up on learning, but we also think AI will be the great equaliser.’’

REFERENCES
■ Li, B., Exter, M., Feng, W., Tang, G. and Xu. K. (2026) A systematic review of language
educators’ practices and development with GenAI. International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education, 36(1-2): https://doi.org/ 10.1016/j.ijaied.2026.100010
■ https://www.ted.com/podcasts/www.
ted.com/podcasts/sal-khan-says-ai-wont-destroy-education-transcript
■ https://www.ted.com/talks/sal_ khan_how_ai_could_save_not_
destroy_education
This article was originally published in the May/June issue of EL Gazette.





