European Parliament questions Commission about sudden closure of Lettori Case. Henry Rodgers reports.
Lettori, the non-national foreign language and culture teaching staff in Italian universities, have stepped up their campaign against the European Commission’s sudden decision to close the third of its infringement cases against Italy for non-implementation of the Court of Justice case law in their favour. The Court first found for the Commission in its infringement ruling of 2001.
The third of the infringement proceedings was opened in September 2021 and referred to the Court of Justice in July 2023 by then Commissioner Nicolas Schmit. In response to a question placed by seven Irish members of the last European Parliament, Nicolas Schmit explained that the Commission had referred the case to the Court because May 2023 legislation introduced by Italy had not “addressed the main grievance of the case, i.e. the payment of the due arrears to the Lettori”. These “due arrears” equate to compensatory settlements for discriminatory working conditions from the date of first employment.
Asso.CEL.L, a Lettori association formed at “La Sapienza” University of Rome, and FLC CGIL, Italy’s largest trade union, together represent the vast majority of the Lettori across Italy. A Census of Discriminatory Conditions in Italian Universities, which they conducted in April 2021, was influential in the Commission’s decision to open the third infringement proceedings. Over the course of the proceedings they sent regular updates of the Census to the Commission services.
In February 2025, Alina-Stefania Ujupan, Head of the Cabinet of current Commissioner Roxana Mînzatu, wrote to FLC CGIL General-Secretary Gianni Fracassi that in October 2024 Italy had informed the Commission that the arrears due to all eligible Lettori had been paid. She gave the union just one month to produce evidence to counter Italy’s claim.
Within this tight schedule Asso.CEL.L and FLC CGIL conducted a further Census. The results showed that in 31 of the 39 participating universities the conditions identified by then Commissioner Schmit as grounds for the referral of the case to the Court of Justice still persisted: the backdated payments due to the Lettori for reconstruction of career had not been made.
However, the Commission subsequently refused to examine the very Census data it had requested and instead sent it to the Italian authorities for their comments. In a strongly worded letter Secretary- General Fracassi reminded the Commission that as Guardian of the Treaty and the Treaty right to parity of treatment it was its duty to examine the Census data. A European Times commentator described the Commission’s action as the equivalent of asking the defence to rule on the case against it.
In a reply of 10 June 2025 to a first parliamentary question from Irish MEP and barrister Cynthia Ní Mhurchu, Commissioner Mînzatu informed her that the Lettori case was pending before the Court of Justice. This was consistent with the Commission’s position in letters to Asso.CEL.L and FLC CGIL. Indeed in a letter of 15 July to FLC CGIL the Commission gave no indication that it would close the case two days later on 17 July.
Incensed by the Commission’s sudden decision to close the case and its refusal to accept Census evidence from Lettori, Asso.CEL.L and FLC CGIL took their campaign to the European Parliament. In particular, members of Asso.CEL.L approached the Irish MEPs, who have been particularly supportive of Lettori in the present and earlier parliaments.
On 20 October, MEP Cynthia Ní Mhurchu put down a follow-up and priority question to Commissioner Mînzatu on the sudden closure of the Lettori case. Co-signed by 12 MEPs, eight of them from Ireland , the question reminded the Commission of its position in its reply of 10 June to Ní Mhurchu and asked for an explanation of what had happened in the interval to cause the Commission to close the case on 17 July.
The controversy over the sudden closure is added to by Commissioner Mînzatu’s failure to address important legal points about the case raised in earlier parliamentary questions by Irish MEPs. By contrast, in the parliaments of the Member States questions put down on the Lettori case by their constituency representatives have received a full answer.
Kurt Rollin is Asso.CEL.L representative for retired Lettori. Commenting on the closure of the Lettori case, Mr. Rollin said: “The sovreiginity ceded by the Member State signatories to the Treaties of European Union was supposedly for a common and greater good. However, it is not for the common good that citizens of the Union should cede their right to defend themselves against Treaty injustices to the whim of the European Commission. The Commission’s failure to respond to questions on the lettori case from members of the European Parliament runs counter to the basic principles of a democracy.”
In accordance with the Rules of Procedure of the European Parliament, the Commission has three weeks within which to reply to Ní Mhurchu’s prioriy question. In practice replies often take longer.





