HomeReviews & ResourcesBook of the MonthReview: Stories of Mentoring Teacher - Research

Review: Stories of Mentoring Teacher – Research

Wayne Trotman reviews ‘Stories of Mentoring Teacher-Research’, edited by Richard Smith, Seden Eraldemir Tuyan, Mariana Serra and Erzsébet Agnes Békés.

Stories of Mentoring Teacher-Research, a timely publication, consists of twenty concise reflective accounts written by experienced teachers who outline how they mentored and facilitated teacher-research (TR). These practitioners are largely based in the Global South, i.e, Argentina, Bangladesh and Cameroon. To clarify, since the term is quite often confused, ‘teacher-research’ is research initiated and carried out by teachers into issues of importance to them in their own work. Thus, researching the classrooms and ELT contexts of others cannot be categorised as TR.

For some, TR is (unfairly, in my opinion) too often equated with time-wasting or ‘re inventing the wheel’. From such persons we hear acerbic comments like. “We already knew that, so why don’t you just get on with your classroom teaching?” The more enlightened teacher-researcher might retort, “Well, until I investigated, I didn’t know it was the case in my own classroom.” And anyway, there’s nothing wrong with TR replication studies, is there? (Actually, I’m not sure the editors would agree with me on that point; I shall let readers decide.)

Eager teachers wishing to investigate matters that concern their everyday practice do not simply become effective researchers overnight; in my own institution, for example, colleagues and I were initially fortunate to have an experienced mentor to guide us. However, such mentors tend to move on to pastures new, making it important for networks such as MenTRnet (http://mentrnet.net/) to be established. This is a voluntary international network for TR, currently numbering over 300 mentors or prospective mentor members worldwide.

Stories that are told

In association with the IATEFL Research SIG, this is MenTRnet’s first publication; more will certainly follow, I’m sure. The driving force behind MenTRnet is Richard Smith, who has worked tirelessly in the last ten years or so on projects related to TR (and no doubt clocked up a mountain of airmiles). One outcome is the dynamic editorial committee for this publication, that has brought to readers emerging stories of how the investigative approach termed ‘Exploratory Action Research’ (EAR) has been successfully implemented in institutions worldwide. These accounts are termed ‘stories’ since the aim was not to introduce academic reports, but to inspire others to engage in teacher-research mentoring.

Many of the stories concern work in difficult situations. In chapter one, Mayamin Altae, based in Qatar reveals how hers took place amidst a back-drop of armed conflict in war-torn Iraq; and a lack of support from the Ministry of Education. She explains how meetings and training with her seven mentees concerning the unasked for implementation of a radical curriculum based upon Sharia education took place on Zoom while civil war raged outside the window in places like Mosul, and how she created a safe space for mentally exhausted teachers obliged to work within contrasting political agendas.

Nahla Nassar in chapter fourteen outlines how she mentored twenty-seven pre-service English teachers at a teacher education college in Israel, the majority of whom were teaching in schools in the Arab sector. Given recent events, far from the conflict and chaos one might expect, Nahla was able to provide personalised guidance. She remains completely upbeat, and for the future aims to engage in peer collaboration – an attitude certain political leaders in that region and elsewhere might well take note of.

Happily, not all stories unfold in extraordinary circumstances. Full credit should be given to all mentors involved; they were largely working on a voluntary basis and simply curious to witness how their projects might turn out. Those who still have doubts about the effect of TR mentoring or being mentored to carry out TR should read this book carefully. And a visit to sign up at mentrnet.net would be the next logical move.

Stories of Mentoring Teacher-Research Edited by Richard Smith, Seden Eraldemir Tuyan, Mariana Serra and Erzsébet Agnes Békés Published by IATEFL Research SIG / MenTRnet, 2024
ISBN: 978-1-912588-50-3

Image courtesy of Library
Wayne Trotman
Wayne Trotman
Wayne is a teacher educator at Izmir Katip Celebi University in Izmir, Turkey. Wayne has been involved in language teaching both in the UK and overseas since 1981. He holds an MSc in TESOL from Aston University and a PhD in ELT and Applied Linguistics from the University of Warwick.
OTHER POSTS
- Advertisment -

Latest Posts