Adjusting assumptions and learning tasks can help teachers feel less challenged by EFL student silences in both face-to-face and online settings, according to a study by Chi Kim Pham from RPT University, Can Tho, Vietnam.
Even in the most teacher-centred classroom, language learning generally requires students to interact verbally with the teacher and with other students. But it is not uncommon to find that invitations to answer questions or take part in group role playing activities are met with silence, both in the physical classroom and even more so online.
Research into the role of silence in this context is very limited compared to studies on the more active parts of language learning and has been more from the students’ than the teachers’ perspectives. Chi Kim Pham’s study sought to address this gap.
Previous student feedback has referred to both negative and positive aspects of silence during EFL lessons. Students may be anxious about their skills and about being judged by both teachers and peers. It may be that some students are generally shy and less communicative in any setting, but students also experience silence as time to reflect and consolidate on the learning.
The situation is further complicated during online classes where there may be issues with the technology and other distractions due to not having a dedicated, quiet study area. Since teachers are not mind readers, however, silence when active participation is invited can be challenging to interpret and depressing to experience.
Chi Kim Pham recruited five lecturers from a private Vietnamese university teaching intermediate and advanced English both face-to-face and online. The lecturers gave semi-structured interviews that were recorded and transcribed, then subjected to thematic analysis. This involved coding the transcripts to develop themes addressing the research question: ‘In what ways do EFL lecturers perceive Vietnamese undergraduates’ silence in face-to-face and online EFL learning?’
Overall, the less experienced lecturers tended to interpret student silences more negatively than their more experienced colleagues. This was especially the case for online classes, where students might choose not to connect their camera or microphone; as one commented: “As for online learning, I still encourage students to open cameras, but very few do so. So, students think they are not being controlled, so they do their own things without their attention.”
Lecturers found it more difficult to interpret the reason for students’ silence online: “…some students are passive, not about learning but about exchanging information. Even if the students understand the material, they do not respond; similarly, if they do not understand, they also remain silent.” The more experienced lecturers thought that silent students were still learning, whether actively or passively, while the less experienced lecturers felt more frustrated and took silence to show complete disengagement: “Sometimes I feel like I am alone in class.”
This contrasted with face-to-face learning where non-verbal cues were more apparent: “The students were silent, but their eyes could see what everyone was doing, still observing, listening, evaluating and understanding. I still feel like they’re learning.”
Overall, the perceived challenge of silence depended on both the experience of the lecturer and the modality – on or offline, with less experienced lecturers teaching online having the most negative experiences.
As education moves increasingly online, teachers of all subjects are learning that adapting face-to-face lessons needs careful consideration, especially where student engagement is concerned. Other ways of participating beyond simple verbal responses should be incorporated, such as open-ended rather than yes/no questions; using chat messaging or breakouts for collaborative activities such as jigsaws, peer-to-peer learning and think-pair-share, which can work equally well on or offline.
But another important takeaway from this study is to encourage teachers to be less anxious about student silence and not assume the worst. Some lecturers noted that they themselves had sometimes been silent students, especially online, and that sometimes this meant they were engaged – and sometimes not. Yet they continued to learn: “I also feel my students’ presence even though they do not answer me… I was a student online; I would have turned it off… but I study, so I am fine.”
Reference
Chi Kim Pham (2025) A phenomenographic study of lecturers’ perspectives on undergraduate silence in face-to-face and online EFL learning, Cogent Education, 12:1, 2562351, DOI: 10.1080/2331186X.2025.2562351.
This article was originally published in the November issue of EL Gazette. Read it for free HERE.





