Home2025 IssuesFeel the fear

Feel the fear

Gill Ragsdale uncovers research which reveals that anxiety can increase motivation.

A study by Zhanni Lui and Yuanlu Xiong from Chongquing Normal University in China found that both facilitating and debilitating anxiety increased extrinsic and intrinsic motivation as well as perceived competence but not academic performance of college language students.

It is not unusual for language students to feel anxious. They have plenty to worry about: are people judging their pronunciation and will they pass their exams? Previous research and conventional wisdom suggest that fear and anxiety do not support language learning.

This study looked at two kinds of anxiety. In general, ‘facilitating anxiety’ by definition, tends to be beneficial, for example by increasing focus and concentration. Alternatively, ‘debilitating anxiety’ tends to be harmful, making the desired outcome less achievable. In the context of language learning, however, the role of these different kinds of anxiety is unclear – a gap Lui and Xiong sought to fill.

In particular, they wanted to know how these types of anxiety influence intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, EFL competence and academic performance, as well as how facilitating and debilitating anxiety interact directly.

A 24-item questionnaire

To test these relationships, Lui and Xiong put together a 24-item questionnaire using previously validated subscales from other questionnaires. For example, a student agreeing with ‘Nervousness while taking a test helps me do better’ is indicating facilitating anxiety while a student agreeing with ‘Nervousness while taking a test stops me from doing well’ is expressing debilitating anxiety. The questionnaire was completed by 476 students from universities across China.

The authors then applied structural equation modelling to identify how the different factors included in the questionnaire influenced each other.

Surprisingly, both facilitating and debilitating anxiety had significant positive influences on both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, and EFL competence. Furthermore, facilitating anxiety was found to increase debilitating anxiety. But neither kind of anxiety impacted actual academic performance.

Looking more closely at the results, although both kinds of anxiety increase motivation, the subcomponents of motivation are not increased equally. Facilitating anxiety most strongly influences the type of extrinsic motivation referred to as ‘identified regulation’ where the externally motivating factor has become part of the student’s identity: it is part of who they are. This is reflected in agreement with statements such as ‘I learn English because it is important in our society’.

Debilitating anxiety, however, most strongly influences extrinsic motivation via ‘introjected regulation’. This kind of motivation stems from feelings of obligation and guilt as reflected in statements such as ‘I learn English because I do not want to disappoint my family’. Guilt and obligation are somewhat joyless motivators, and it would be interesting to see how these different routes to extrinsic motivation impact students’ emotional well-being and general learning experience.

Competence, in terms of language skills and abilities, is stable across all contexts while performance is specific, for example in response to an exam. Although competence predicts academic performance these are distinct entities and only the former was positively influenced by anxiety in this study while the impact on performance was decidedly neutral. Given the common experience of ‘exam nerves’ this is also surprising – and perhaps reassuring, although this needs further investigation.

As this study relied on a self-report questionnaire, the rating of competence was inevitably subjective. For example, students rated as more competent more strongly agreed with statements such as ‘My English reading ability is sufficient for my study’ which is a good deal more subjective than ‘Overall, I can get high scores in English tests’, which signals strong academic performance. This raises the interesting possibility that anxiety might lead students to over-rate (rather than under-rate) their competence.

Taken together, these results suggest that the role of anxiety in language learning is more complicated than previously thought and that debilitating and facilitating anxiety are not so easily distinguished. Both teachers and students should feel encouraged to tackle activities that are challenging enough to provoke anxiety without being overwhelming: to ‘feel the fear and do it anyway’.

Reference

Luo, Z and Xiong, Y. (2025) Is anxiety always harmful? An exploration of the impact of language anxiety on EFL learning motivation, EFL competence and ELF academic performance. BMC Psychology, 13: 674.  https://doi.org/10.1186/s40359-025-03017-z

Image courtesy of Library
Becci Knowles
Becci Knowles
With two decades of experience in business and consumer press, Becci has contributed to many leading titles. She holds a degree in English and American Literature from the University of Kent at Canterbury and has experience as an ELT.
OTHER POSTS
- Advertisment -

Latest Posts