Simon Moran delves into the high-pressure world of staff management, revealing why finding, training and keeping the right team is the ultimate test for any leader.
Sooner or later, every independent school owner runs into the same problem. You may have opened the school because you are a good teacher, but once the student numbers rise, teaching well is no longer enough. You now need other people to teach well too, and that is where things become more complicated.
Finding, training and keeping good teachers is one of the hardest parts of building a school. It is also one of the things that most determines whether a school stays small and owner-dependent or grows into something more durable. Recruitment, training and staff management cannot really be separated. Hiring the wrong people creates training problems. Training badly creates management problems. Managing badly creates retention problems.
When I first started taking on staff, I had rather fixed ideas about what I wanted. I thought that if I paid above market rates, I would attract better teachers.
I also tried to ask clever questions in interviews, hoping the answers would reveal whether the people were interesting, creative and suitable. Some of that worked, but not as much as I imagined. Good pay matters, of course, but money alone does not produce loyalty, nor does it tell you much about how someone will actually perform once they are standing in front of students. Over time I became less interested in what candidates claimed to be, and more interested in what they were like as people, how they thought and how they dealt with others.
Qualifications and experience matter, but only up to a point. A certificate does not guarantee warmth, sound judgement, reliability or adaptability. Nor does experience necessarily mean someone can thrive in your school. A teacher may have worked for years in a heavily scripted chain school and be completely lost in a more flexible environment. Another may have worked only a short time, but have exactly the personality, energy and potential you need. For us, the best indicators have tended to be friendliness, reliability, adaptability, creativity and the ability to get on with people from different ages and backgrounds. Teaching skill matters, obviously, but personality and demeanour matter just as much. Students notice them immediately.
That is why recruitment needs to go beyond CVs and polite conversation. We always ask teachers to do a short demo lesson. However well someone interviews, the real test is what happens when they interact with a learner. Can they build rapport? Can they explain simply? Can they respond naturally when something
Over time I became less interested in what candidates claimed to be, and more interested in what they were like as people, how they thought and how they dealt with others.
unexpected happens? Can they keep the lesson moving without panicking? A demo tells you far more than a polished answer to a standard interview question.
References matter too, and they should actually be checked. It still surprises me how often schools skip this. When speaking to referees, the most useful questions are not always about technical teaching ability. Reliability, trustworthiness, collegiality and common sense often matter more. If a previous employer would not hire the person again, you need to know why.
Let’s talk training
Once you have recruited someone suitable, the next challenge is training. Small schools often get this wrong because they either assume an experienced teacher needs no training, or they try to cram everything into a rushed induction and hope for the best. Neither works. Even experienced teachers need training in your systems, your expectations, your students, your materials and your standards. Newer teachers need all of that plus support in the basics of lesson planning, classroom management, grammar explanation and age-appropriate teaching. Good training is not a one-off event. It is an ongoing process.
At its best, training should combine manuals, modelling, observation, feedback and reflection. Teachers need something concrete to refer to, so written systems and manuals matter. They also need to see good teaching in practice, which means observation and demonstration matter too. After that, they need feedback that is specific enough to be useful but not so heavy-handed that it crushes confidence. Then the process repeats. Observe again. Review progress. Ask what is working and what is not. Encourage teachers to reflect on their own lessons and continue improving. The best teachers remain learners.
Regular meetings are part of this. So is creating proper channels for ideas to come back from staff. A school where information flows only from the owner downwards is usually a school that stops improving. Good teachers notice problems, spot opportunities and often have strong ideas about how to improve materials, systems and lessons. If they are never asked, or if suggestions disappear into a void, they quickly stop offering them. Bringing staff together, occasionally closing the school for proper training, or bringing in an outside speaker can all help keep standards fresh and prevent the school from becoming stale.
Provide a framework
The more difficult balancing act is management. Independent school owners often start their own business because they are frustrated by rigid systems elsewhere. They want to do things better, more humanely, more creatively. Yet as soon as they employ other people, they discover an awkward truth – unless every teacher is to be completely free to do whatever they like, some form of system is unavoidable. You cannot promise students and parents clear outcomes, consistency and accountability if every teacher operates entirely by instinct. Rules are necessary. The trick is to have enough structure to create standards, without imposing so much that you strangle the teacher in the classroom.
This is where many schools go wrong. They either have no real system at all, and chaos results, or they over-correct and script everything so tightly that teachers become delivery machines. Neither approach builds a strong school. A better approach is to provide a framework – curriculum, admin systems, lesson aims, progress tracking and clear standards – and then allow teachers room within that framework to bring lessons to life. I have always thought of curriculum and systems as the skeleton. They give shape, support and consistency. The teacher then adds the colour, or the flesh to the bones. The system should remove drudgery, repetition and guesswork. It should not eliminate judgement, initiative or personality.
Good management also depends on trust, and trust is earned in both directions. The owner or manager must trust staff enough to give them room to work. Staff, in turn, must trust that the school’s systems are sensible, that support will be there when needed and that freedom will not suddenly be withdrawn at the first small mistake. Not every employee should be managed in exactly the same way. Some need close guidance at first. Some can assess a problem and propose solutions.

Part of management is knowing which level
of direction each person needs at a given time and helping them move towards greater
autonomy where possible.
A few can simply be told to deal with it and left to get on with the job. Part of management is knowing which level of direction each person needs at a given time and helping them move towards greater autonomy where possible.
Retention, finally, is not just about pay. Of course, salaries and conditions matter, and poor conditions will drive good people away. But teachers also stay when they feel trusted, useful and connected to something larger than their timetable. People are more likely to remain when they feel they contribute not just lessons, but ideas, materials, systems and value to the wider business. Some may contribute as writers, designers, trainers, curriculum developers or managers. Giving people a sense of ownership does not always mean literal shares in the company. It may simply mean recognising that they are helping to build something worthwhile, and that their contribution is seen.
In the end, staff management in a school is not about controlling teachers. It is about creating the conditions in which good teachers can do their best work consistently, and weaker teachers can improve. Recruit carefully, train continuously, manage clearly and build systems that support rather than suffocate. Get that right and you are no longer just employing teachers – you are building a school that can outgrow dependence on any one individual, including yourself.
This article was originally published in the May/June issue of EL Gazette.





